I’m shocked, SHOCKED! to learn that insider trading happens before big deals are announced. I can’t imagine Wall Street lining its own pockets while fleecing the rest of us! My whole world view is shaken to its very core! [/sarcasm]
Of course, it’s illegal to use insider knowledge to buy and sell stocks. But, really, when has the law really stopped anyone from making money before? A lot of Wall Street has become so focused on greed and moneymaking that not even securities laws seem to stop people from making every dollar they can. It seems like every month something else comes to light to show how people are cheating on their taxes, cheating on their financial statements, or cheating on their trading.
So, how does the information get out? Well, with brokerages increasing becoming a one-stop shop, it’s easy for information to leak from the M&A department to the trading department. Of course, the brokerage houses claim that it isn’t happening, but the data is undeniable.
Trading quadrupled in a particular stock on the day that investors came to check the books. According to the NYTimes analysis, the company was not involved in any pre-merger speculation to explain the anomaly. Another stock jumped when GE contacted the CEO of the takeover target and offered to raise its bid by 5%.
The largest deal that appears to have benefited from insider trading was the purchase of Georgia-Pacific last year. In the two trading days before the deal was announced, trading in the stock increased by 127% over its year average. That coincided exactly with the day that Koch agreed on a price, but the deal was not announced for three days. The kicker? A month earlier, Koch had told Georgia-Pacific that a deal could not be struck and trading in the stock had dropped from the earlier fervent speculation of a takeover.
In another surprise deal, Wachovia purchased Golden West Financial. On the deal that Wachovia’s board met to consider a deal the call option activity tripled. The deal wasn’t announced for another five days and was a surprise as Golden West was largely considered too large to take over.
So, what can you do? Not really much. Some say insider trading is a victimless crime, and that appears to be the rationalization in these cases. But is it? Wouldn’t the person who sold the shares for much less than they were worth be victimized? Their only crime was not being well-connected enough.
This is another example of why I don’t invest in individual stocks. Wall Street is a fool’s game for those that don’t have buddies at the trading desks at Goldman or Merrill Lynch. Can you make money? Sure, but you are always running the risk of being cheated by those that have insider information or by those that backdate options or those that know the books are cooked.